The Semiconductor Industry Association released global semiconductor sales data for the month of February, 2007, and it did not look good.
Worldwide sales of semiconductors of $20.09 billion in February were 6.5 percent lower than January when sales were $21.48 billion, the Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) reported today. February sales increased by 4.2 percent from the $19.28 billion recorded in February 2006.“While seasonality clearly contributed to the 6.5 percent decline in worldwide chip sales month-on-month, declining unit shipments and lower average selling prices (ASPs) in several key market segments were a factor,” said SIA President George Scalise. “Both unit shipments and total sales of microprocessors and DSP chips experienced sequential declines in February. Unit shipments of NAND flash increased sequentially while total sales saw a double-digit decline, indicating very competitive market conditions.”
It reminds us of something we said in February: Although end demand for semiconductors has experienced fairly steady growth, excess supply has sometimes caused inventory to grow to unsustainable levels. For example, “by 2000 most of the capacity was in place, churning out chips. Since end demand was growing at a slower pace, inventory built up. The falloff in 2001 wasn’t so much a drop in demand, but the fact that the demand could be filled from that existing inventory.” We even backed it up with this chart:
We followed up last week, saying “Next we turn to capacity utilization, which has clearly started to fall. Excess capacity means the potential for even more inventory to be produced, which tends to put downward pressure on prices. Since the majority of semiconductor manufacturing costs are fixed, low utilization means lower profits - either because prices have to be reduced or because the per-unit costs are higher when production is cut.” It sounds very similar to what Scalise described in today’s SIA press release:
“Year-on-year, we see evidence of the fiercely competitive market conditions – across the board unit sales in key products increased, while ASPs declined. Unit sales of microprocessors were up almost 8 percent while ASPs declined 15 percent, and NAND flash units grew by over 40 percent while experiencing a nearly 50 percent drop in ASPs. These products tend to be indicators of conditions in important end markets such as personal computers and consumer devices,” Scalise continued. “Personal computers and consumer products now account for approximately 60 percent of semiconductor sales. Both competitive conditions and product mix issues appear to be affecting revenues of these key components.”
SIA noted that overall capacity utilization declined from 88.9 percent in the third quarter of 2006 to 86.8 percent in the fourth quarter. Most of the decline was in foundry utilization, which fell from 91.5 percent in the third quarter to 80.9 percent in the fourth quarter. The reduction in capacity utilization in the fourth quarter addressed inventory builds in the semiconductor supply chain and selected end markets which are expected to show growth consistent with GDP performance in key world markets in the coming months.
The problem for us is, we don’t see the reduction in capacity utilization as having “addressed inventory builds.” Rather, we see it as the logical conclusion of excess capacity expansion that has built up now for more than a year:
At the time, we said:
The good thing about the downward revision, and also the decline in February, is that it restores some balance to at least the trend in equipment orders relative to end demand for semiconductors. Although supply (chip equipment orders) is still growing much faster than the roughly 10% growth in semiconductor demand, at least the rate at which the capacity is growing is starting to slow down again. Furthermore, the billings (which represent what is actually installed rather than orders, which may prove too optimistic) have been running at a slower rate than orders. The 22% growth of installed equipment is still well higher than what is needed, but has less far to fall.
Unfortunately, today’s release also blows a hole in any hopes we had that slowing orders would restore balance. Since we measure the imbalance as the differential between dollar capacity growth and dollar sales growth, the slowdown in semi demand to 4% year/year from “roughly 10%” means that February’s decline in chip orders did not improve the potential supply imbalance. Things have farther to fall than we thought.
Disclosure: William Trent has a long position in SMH.
